The Fallacy of “Either You Have It or You Don’t”

I love art and I love music, okay, they are both art forms but you get the picture. If you are in the creative community you will hear some elitist views like the one we’re talking about today. Have you ever heard the phrase, “Either you have it or you don’t”? It’s a common saying that suggests certain abilities or talents are inherent and cannot be developed. But is this really true? Can we really categorize people into those who “have it” and those who don’t?

Let’s examine this concept using an analogy. Imagine a garden with different types of plants. Some plants may naturally flourish in their environment, while others may struggle to grow. However, with proper care, attention, and cultivation, even the struggling plants can thrive and blossom.

Similarly, when it comes to talents or abilities, it is not just a matter of having them or not.

While some individuals may possess certain innate skills or inclinations, everyone has the potential to develop and improve their abilities through dedication and hard work.

Take the example of musical talent.

Some people seem to be born with an exceptional ear for music, effortlessly composing beautiful melodies or playing intricate pieces on various instruments. But does that mean those without such natural talent should give up on pursuing music altogether? Absolutely not!

Many renowned musicians and composers throughout history did not start out as prodigies but worked tirelessly to hone their craft. Wolfgang Amadeus Mozart is often hailed as a child prodigy in music; however, his early compositions were far from perfect. Only through years of practice and refinement did he reach the level of mastery we now associate with his name.

So here’s where external sources come into play. If you find yourself doubting your own abilities or feeling discouraged by comparing yourself to others who seem more talented, remember that even great artists had humble beginnings.

One book that might inspire you is “Art & Fear” by David Bayles and Ted Orland. This insightful book explores the challenges faced by artists and the importance of persistence in overcoming self-doubt and creative obstacles.

It’s also crucial to consider the historical context of artistic development. Throughout history, certain art forms or styles were deemed superior while others were dismissed as lesser. However, these judgments often reflect societal biases rather than objective measures of talent.

For example, during the Renaissance period, realistic oil paintings were highly valued, while abstract or impressionist works were considered inferior. But as time went on and perspectives evolved, artists like Claude Monet and Vincent van Gogh revolutionized the art world with their unique styles that challenged conventional norms.

By exploring diverse perspectives and pushing boundaries in defining taste within art forms like music or painting, we can expand our own understanding and appreciation for different expressions of creativity.

Remember, personal growth and reflection are essential in any craft or activity. Embrace your journey, knowing that it is through perseverance and a positive mindset that you can surpass limitations and achieve greatness.

So next time someone tells you “either you have it or you don’t,” remember that it’s not about having some mysterious innate quality but about embracing the process of growth and improvement. You have the power to cultivate your talents and make your mark in whatever field you choose.